Login Register
 
Email RSS Feed Twitter Facebook YouTube

Medal of Honor: review of reviews

Medal of Honor: review of reviews

The Medal of Honour reviews have hit, and here I’ll take you through the best and worst of them. Why write a review of reviews? Well MOH is a huge game, a controversial one and a big deal for EA. The marketing is off the scale, the subject matter is controversial and the game has not been out of the news since it was announced. I’m not here to pass judgement on the game (thats for later), I’m just going to evaluate who does the best job of presenting their opinions and backing up their arguments. Here’s how well the major review sites have managed to handle the responsibility of reviewing such an important game.

Gametrailers review
This is probably the gold standard so far. The main criticisms are laid out with a focus on the playing experience above all else. In a video review, what we really want to know is not the background of the EA/Activision fallout (we can read that ourselves), but the quality of the level design, the extent that it imitates the Modern Warfare titles and how successfully it handles the seriousness of the subject matter. Gametrailers reviews typically have a more neutral tone than other sites with a “why not give it a go” usually creeping in towards the end, but this one is more critical and quite simply better than their usual efforts. If you want a review that highlights the gameplay flaws in detail and evaluates the game maturely and responsibly, this is the best so far. Additionally, the video footage used is excelent and supports each point made in the commentary.

9.0 out of 10

IGN review
A serious surpirse here. This video review on IGN was also very good. Despite being a site which favours the big releases, IGN have hit a home run with this review. The criticisms are suitably damning and supported with well reasoned arguments. They seem to be revising their scoring system at the moment. Had I guessed at the score for this beforehand, I would have plumped for a 8.1 out of ten (don’t ask ME why they can’t use whole numbers). They instead score this a six, which sounds fair from the footage they show and the facts they provide.

Unfortunately this video review is inundated with some of the least intelligent comments I have ever seen, even on IGN. The internet is currently groaning under the weight of all the stupid on this site, and these comments threaten to rupture our beloved series of tubes. Here’s some examples:

“Im sorry but i dont belive a single word of that because the review was being WAY to critical “
I shall only believe uncritical reviews.

“Sorry but this guy is being far too harsh and 6.0 is no a fair score given the over scores.”
Other people disagree, so this review is wrong

“sure, it has it’s problems, but which game doesn’t?”
Give games with problems better scores, because if we don’t they’ll be sad

“think about it,this is the first game ever tried to maintain autheticy by working WITH the army! If you guys hate good games, go play haze.”
Pathetic attempts to win over fanboys with “authentic” input from veterans dreamed up by the EA marketing department have sure worked on me! Meanwhile, my obscure reference to a PS3 exclusive hints at some level of trolling too advanced for most normal people to understand!

Hopefully IGN sticks with its newer system and gives this particular reviewer a pat on the back for a job well done while ignoring its cretinous trolls.

IGN Reviewer: 8.9/10, IGN comments 0.1/10

GiantBomb Review
I’ll try not to gush too much here because I’m a big fan of these guys. In this review it’s Jeff Gerstmann who tees off on MOH and he does a good job as always. Giantbomb reviews have that great colloquial feel, you always get the impression that they are clever, knowledgeable gamers who are looking out for your hard earned cash. Occasionally this means there writing isn’t particularly clever or witty, but it is direct, honest and concise. In the review Gerstmann takes us through his issues with the game, highlights the god and bad and puts the whole experience in perspective. At their best, a Giantbomb review is like a clever videogame store owner who has immense game knowledge giving you the bottom line: should you spend money on this or something else. The only difference is the Giantbomb guys aren’t rude as fuck and don’t smell like BBQ monster munch (hopefully).

4/5

Eurogamer review
Of all the review I read, this was the one that I was most personally disappointed with. Tom Bramwell is a great reviewer and seems like a nice guy, so I can’t help but think that he wanted to say more on MOH, and maybe wanted to be more critical than he was. Eurogamer always has a higher standard of writing than the other sites, and Bramwell brilliantly opens the review in a way that’s both considerate and humorous. At its best, Eurogamer review read well and can be poignant and funny, but at their worst you get the feeling that the reviewer would rather be doing something else. In this case Bramwell’s apparent distaste for the tone of the game is the best part, but the corresponding criticism of the gameplay itself is weaker. About halfway through the review you can feel Bramwell’s interest in the whole thing wane along with your own. Overall though this is a must read as most other reviewers opt out of the debate on the appropriateness of the setting, but Bramwell’s brave enough to stand out and attempt to tackle the more controversial issues surrounding the game.

7 out of 10


Joystiq review

One of the weakest reviews, Joystiq is in some ways a mirror image of Eurogamer. While the review is strong on the gameplay aspects, its consideration of the issues surrounding the game is poor and internally inconsistent. Despite mentioning that the game talks about September 11th in the first minute, the review goes on to say that MOH is “unquestionably a pro-American game, (MOH’s) narrative isn’t about politics, or the morality of war”. It seems to me that if the game frames the conflict in Afghanistan as the result of the September 11th attacks then it is most definitely making a political statement, and that statement is implicit in everything you do (and everyone you kill) throughout the game.

Joystiqs review also focuses on the multiplayer aspect far more than any of the other sites. This is to the detriment of the rest; most gamers will have played Bad Company at some point so will have a clear idea of how this section of the game plays. Additionally, many of the statements made in this review contradict ALL of the other reviews as regards the quality of the single player experience and the polish of the game. While this does not mean that Joystiq is wrong, it would seem likely that they are glossing over problems. The alternative is that every other site is imagining those same problems and they simply don’t exist.

2 out of 5

Gamespot Review
So how does the site with zero credibility do? Written in a breathy, intern-trying-to-impress-his-boss-with-his-first-review style, this review nonetheless covers all the basics. There’s some factual errors (the enemy are no longer called the Taliban, maybe you heard a news story about that?), but the text conveys the main issues with the gameplay well enough. There’s a complete absence of comment on the issues surrounding the game, and on this site it seems a little cowardly. Overall, this is not a terrible effort, but if you want to know how serious a reviewer is about the quality of their work you should read their last sentence. In this case, it seems like the author finished the end of this review while lapsing into an apathetic coma.

4.5 out of 10

MOAR FROM CALMDOWNTOM!

24 Comments

Leave A Reply
  1. 07/01/2015, 10:16 AM

    I’ve been browsing online more than three hours nowadays,
    yet I by no means discovered any fascinating article like
    yours. It’s beautiful price sufficient for me. Personally, if all web owners and bloggers made good content
    as you probably did, the net will likely be much
    more helpful than ever before.

  2. 10/09/2014, 2:18 PM

    Quality artices or reviews is the secret to be a foxus for the users to go to see the webb page, that’s what
    this sitte is providing.

  3. 10/05/2014, 1:13 PM

    Hello, its fastidious article regarding media print, we all understand media is a wonderful
    source of data.

  4. 10/03/2014, 11:21 PM

    Please let me know if you’re looking for a author for your blog.
    You have some really good articles and I feel I would
    be a good asset. If you ever want to take some of the load off, I’d really like to write some material for
    your blog in exchange for a link bacxk to mine.Please shoot me an email if interested.

    Regards!

  5. 10/02/2014, 6:08 AM

    On top of this, Amazon is also working on introducing a new show to woo
    its audience. While this mug might look great and have some nice features,
    based on the customer reviews we suggest you steer clear from this
    product for good. Best of all, you will never
    know what you can find.

  6. 10/01/2014, 8:01 AM

    Thanks designed for sharing such a pleasant idea, paragraph is nice, thats why i have read it completely

  7. Jaqueline says
    09/29/2014, 7:54 PM

    Website Creation (Mississauga ,Brampton,Hamilton ,Oakville,Milton),website positioning Mississauga providers will keep
    adjusting the brand construction right up until their
    clients is delighted. But the color business cards are the ones which are noticeable and appealing.

    As well as preparation your web site develop you have got to jump into
    the footwear to your potential customers who see your Web Design in Mississauga , seo Mississauga , Web Design Markham , Web Design North York,Web
    Design Woodbridge,Web Design Stoney Creek , to analyze their access-guidelines and factor.

  8. 09/29/2014, 8:34 AM

    But even there, 10 minutes are often enough for an experienced burglar to
    rummage through a house and has no money, mortgage companies and insurance companies are not
    particularly good at paying their bills. If youre having difficulty finding
    cheap cover, it is unlikely to be passed before elections due in early 2009
    for the firm’s benefits division, Athens Benefits.
    Fully comprehensive willl also cover abc you for a
    lost or stolen.

  9. 09/26/2014, 2:58 PM

    Hmm it looks like your website ate my first comment (it was extremely
    long) so I guess I’ll just sum it up what I submitted and say, I’m thoroughly enjoying your
    blog. I as well am an aspiring blog blogger but I’m still new to everything.
    Do you have any tips and hints for novice blog writers?
    I’d definitely appreciate it.

  10. 09/25/2014, 5:52 AM

    Hello, this weekend is pleasant in support of me, for the reason that this occasion i am reading this impressive educational article here at my home.

  11. 09/24/2014, 8:26 PM

    Arnold does donkey calf raises with two girls on his back as they laughingly
    count out the reps in German.

  12. 09/24/2014, 6:55 PM

    Hey There. I found your blog using msn. This is an extremely well written article.
    I’ll make sure to bookmark it and return to read more of your
    useful information. Thanks for the post. I’ll definitely return.

  13. 09/24/2014, 5:56 PM

    Tell people why you or your browser after oone hour’s
    operation, aan estimated 50 millionvisitors in July 2007, poker gams in a suspijcious accident.
    The Nintendo 3DS, like Ubisoft’s” Assassin’s Creeed gaming Revelations, will be participating so I gguess at hhow Madden NFL 13. Thursday June 28thThursdaay Night Fights at GameClucks in Lynnwood featuring Super Street Fighter 4 AE 2012, From NewYork, United States, and Facebook annd Zynga. Understanding casino repayment percentawges and how they knew whether they need too drool over the phone they have a sense of insecurity and worries of losing everything.

  14. 09/24/2014, 10:00 AM

    great issues altogether, you just won a new reader.
    What would you recommend in regards to your post that you made a few days
    in the past? Any certain?

  15. 09/24/2014, 4:14 AM

    My relatives always say that I am killing my time here at web,
    but I know I am getting familiarity all the time by reading such
    good content.

  16. 09/19/2014, 2:16 PM

    It’s actually a nice and helpful piece of information. I am glad that you simply shared this helpful info with us.
    Please stay us informed like this. Thank you for sharing.

  17. op Youtube says
    09/18/2014, 4:47 AM

    – Steek steamer in een steelpan en vul met water
    tot net onder de onderkant van de stomer. Caseïne kan toegevoegd worden aan niet-verwerkte producten. Fruit seizoen in de winter maanden kan vervangen door perziken en aardbeien met grapefruits,
    kanteloep (geschild en sinaasappelen.

  18. Luann says
    09/14/2014, 4:39 AM

    Hello to every body, it’s my first visit of this web site;
    this web site consists of awesome aand actually excellent stuff in support of visitors.

  19. 09/07/2014, 10:32 PM

    Hello there! I could have sworn I’ve been to this website before but after
    reading through some of the post I realized it’s new to me.
    Anyways, I’m definitely happy I found it and I’ll be bookmarking and checking
    back frequently!

  20. 09/04/2014, 9:33 PM

    Toen de nicotine kauwgom en patches kwam ik probeerde hen beiden in een poging
    om te stoppen met roken, maar op een gegeven moment was ik het
    dragen van een hoge sterkte patch, de kauwgom, en het hebben van een sigaret allemaal op hetzelfde moment, dus
    ik kwam tot de conclusie dat ze niet werken. Ik begon te voelen veel beter zodra alle nicotine uit
    mijn systeem was. Wanneer Rookvrije een schijn van kortstondige vrijheid van mentale stress biedt, is het zeer aantrekkelijk.

  21. 09/03/2014, 1:30 PM

    As you level up, you’ll want to put ranks into Mark of the Assassin as often as possible.
    This legendary skin for the Tiny Master of Evil is currently in the League of Legends store for 1820 Riot Points.
    You can also kill the enemy champions for large amounts of experience and gold.

  22. Sung says
    09/03/2014, 7:54 AM

    Definitely believe that which you said. Your favorite justification appeared to be
    on the internet the easiest thing to be aware of.

    I say to you, I certainly get annoyed while people
    consider worries that they plainly do not know about. You managed to hit
    the nail upon the top and defined out the whole thing without having side-effects , people could take a signal.
    Will probably be back to get more. Thanks

  23. 09/02/2014, 2:46 AM

    I am regular reader, how are you everybody? This article posted at this website is
    actually fastidious.

  24. Frank Hardy says
    10/13/2010, 3:37 PM

    Yo dawg, I heard you liked reviews…….

Leave a Reply

Skip to toolbar